Is direct indexing better than ETFs?

It depends on your situation. Direct indexing is better if you have $25K+ invested, pay more than 0.20%/yr in ETF fees, want tax-loss harvesting, or need portfolio customization. ETFs are better for smaller portfolios, ultra-low-cost funds like VTI (0.03%), or investors who prefer zero maintenance.

How much does ETF expense ratio cost over time?

ETF fees compound against you over time. On a $100,000 portfolio at 7% annual growth, a 0.40% expense ratio costs over $81,000 in lost returns over 30 years. Even a 0.09% fee (SPY) costs about $19,000 over the same period. Direct indexing eliminates this cost entirely.

What is tax-loss harvesting and how does it work?

Tax-loss harvesting is selling investments at a loss to offset capital gains taxes. With direct indexing, you own stocks individually, so you can sell losers to harvest losses while keeping winners. ETF holders cannot do this because they own one bundled security. High-income investors in taxable accounts benefit most.

Who is direct indexing suitable for?

Direct indexing is best suited for investors with $25,000 or more in taxable brokerage accounts, those paying 0.20%+ in ETF expense ratios, high-income earners who benefit from tax-loss harvesting, and anyone who wants to exclude or overweight specific stocks for personal or ESG reasons.

What is the difference between an index fund and direct indexing?

An index fund (ETF or mutual fund) pools investor money to buy all stocks in an index, charging an annual expense ratio. Direct indexing means you buy the individual stocks yourself, paying no ongoing fees. You get similar market exposure but with added benefits: zero expense ratio, tax-loss harvesting on individual positions, and full control to customize holdings.

Is direct indexing better than ETFs?

For cost savings alone, yes — you eliminate the expense ratio entirely. But ETFs are simpler to manage. Direct indexing makes most sense for high-expense ETFs (0.4%+/yr) or portfolios above $50,000 where the fee savings are meaningful.

How many stocks do I need to replicate an ETF?

15-20 stocks representing the top holdings achieves R² > 0.95 for most sector ETFs. The top holdings of most ETFs account for 70-80% of the fund's weight, so cap-weighting those stocks closely mirrors the full fund.

What brokers support direct indexing?

Any zero-commission broker works: Interactive Brokers, Fidelity, Schwab, TD Ameritrade. You buy each stock individually. No special account type needed.

What Is Direct Indexing? A Complete Guide

Q: What is direct indexing?

Direct indexing is an investment strategy where you buy the individual stocks that make up an index or ETF instead of buying the fund itself. This eliminates the fund's annual expense ratio and gives you full control over which stocks you hold, enabling tax-loss harvesting and portfolio customization.

The strategy Wall Street charges 0.40%/yr for — available free.

The simple version

When you buy an ETF like SPY or QQQ, you're paying a management fee every year — the expense ratio. SPY charges 0.09%/yr. That sounds small, but on $100,000 invested for 30 years, you give up over $27,000 in compounded returns.

Direct indexing skips the ETF wrapper entirely. Instead of buying SPY, you buy Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Amazon, and the other top holdings directly in your brokerage account. You own the same exposure, pay zero management fees.

How many stocks do you actually need?

Research shows the top holdings of any ETF account for 70-80% of its total weight. For sector ETFs, owning the top 15-20 stocks achieves an R² correlation of over 0.95 — meaning 95% of the fund's price movement is replicated.

You don't need to own all 500 stocks in SPY. You need the top 30-50. For a defence ETF like ITA (0.40%/yr), 15 stocks gets you there — and saves $400/yr on every $100K invested.

Who is it for?

Investors with $25,000+ in a single ETF position (fees start to matter)
Holders of high-fee sector ETFs (ITA, HACK, XLV — 0.4-0.6%/yr)
Anyone at a zero-commission broker (IBKR, Fidelity, Schwab)
People who want control over specific stock exclusions

Direct indexing vs ETFs

	ETF	Direct Index
Annual fee	0.03–0.60%/yr	0%
Stocks needed	1 ticker	15-50 stocks
Rebalancing	Automatic	Manual (or scheduled)
Tax-loss harvesting	Limited	Full control
Custom exclusions	No	Yes
Minimum investment	Any amount	$5,000+

Want a deeper breakdown? Read our full direct indexing vs ETF comparison, including tax benefits. Or learn how tax-loss harvesting works with direct indexing. To see how much you could save in fees, try the ETF expense ratio calculator.

Build your basket for free

Direct Index Club calculates the exact stocks to buy, at what weights, and how much of each — for any of the supported ETFs. Free, no signup.

Start building →